1st Choice Property ManagementFull Service Property Management
Our full service property management program helps Colleyville area homeowners protect their investment and achieve consistent rental income. We assign a dedicated local property manager to you and your home, giving you a single point of contact who understands the Colleyville market and your property’s needs. We handle every part of the rental process including:
- Local Property Marketing
- Tenant Screening
- Leasing
- Maintenance Coordination,
- Inspections
- Rent Collection,
- Accounting
- Legal Compliance
- Evictions
- And Much More!
With deep knowledge of the Colleyville rental market, our team works to reduce vacancy, place quality tenants and improve long term property performance. Whether you are a first time landlord or a seasoned investor, we provide reliable Colleyville property management solutions that keep your home profitable and worry free.
Let us manage your Colleyville Rental Property
Owning a rental in Colleyville is different than owning one in Phoenix, Denver, or even Dallas. We know, because we live here. Our team walks the same neighborhoods, shops at the same grocery stores, and drives the same roads as your tenants. That hometown understanding helps us spot the right tenants, care for homes with long-term value in mind, and protect your property like a neighbor would.
Schedule a Phone Call Today!
Owner or Renter?
Have you thought of everything?
Who will answer the phone in the middle of the night when there is an emergency maintenance issue? Are you up to date with the ever-changing rules and regulations in the Colleyville rental market? How do you make sure rent is collected on time?
When you hire 1st Choice Property Management, we will take care of everything so you can focus on what is most important. Below are just a few of the things we take care of.
Client Reviews
See what property owners and tenants are saying about our reliable service and hands-on management
Property Management Questions
-
How long does it take to rent a home in Colleyville right now?
On average, our homes lease in 14 to 30 days, depending on the property type, price point, and location. Properties that show well, are priced right, and allow pets typically move faster. We provide weekly updates during the leasing period so you're never left wondering how it's going. -
What neighborhoods are moving the fastest?
We're seeing high demand in areas like TCU/Westcliff, Near Southside, Arlington Heights, and parts of North Colleyville near Alliance. Tenants are drawn to walkability, good schools, and access to downtown or major employers. But with the right strategy, we can attract strong tenants in any part of the metro. -
Do you allow pets, and how do you screen them?
Yes — in fact, properties that allow pets typically lease faster and to a broader pool of applicants. But we’re strict. We use a third-party pet screening service that checks for breed restrictions, vaccination records, and pet behavior history. We also charge pet deposits and/or pet rent to protect your property. -
What’s your eviction rate in Colleyville compared to others?
We rarely have to file. Thanks to our screening process and clear expectations upfront, our eviction rate is consistently below 1% — far lower than the local average. But if it ever becomes necessary, we handle everything start to finish. -
How often will I hear from you?
As often as you want. Some owners prefer quarterly check-ins, others want monthly updates. During leasing or maintenance issues, we’re in touch more frequently. You’ll also have 24/7 access to your owner portal — but if you want to call and talk to a real person, we’re here for that too.
you’re protected with Our Pledge
30-Day Pledge
We are so confident we can find you a great tenant that if we are unable to lease your home in 30 days or less, we will give you the first 1 month of management for free!
Eviction
Our tenant screening procedures are so thorough that, if at any time we must evict your tenant, we will cover the filing costs for all court appearances and find a new tenant at no cost to you. See Management Plans for details.
Pet Pledge
Our Full Management Plus plan covers up to $3000 in pet damages, caused by any pet we've approved and screened through PetScreening.com (beyond the security deposit), excluding human-related damages and while reserving the right to pursue tenant neglect. See Management Plans for Details.
Happiness Pledge
We want you to be happy! If for any reason you are not completely satisfied with our services, you can cancel your management agreement at any time and without penalty.
Results Pledge
We don’t collect a dime until you get paid! You can rest easy knowing that we are working hard to find the best tenant for your investment and you will not pay us until you get results.
Leasing Pledge
Our leasing pledge states that if a tenant does not fulfill at least 9 months of a lease term, we will find you a new tenant for free.
Let’s Keep Colleyville Homes Looking Their Best
Schedule Your Free Rental AnalysisWhy Invest a Home in Colleyville
Colleyville, Texas is an upscale residential community located in northeast Tarrant County within the Dallas–Fort Worth metroplex. Known for its high household incomes, estate-style neighborhoods, and strong community standards, Colleyville attracts residents and renters seeking privacy, stability, and long-term suburban living with convenient access to regional employment centers.
Colleyville Population & Housing Demand
Colleyville is a fully built-out city with minimal new residential development, which helps support long-term housing demand. Population levels remain stable, and rental demand is driven primarily by relocation households, executives, and families seeking high-quality single-family homes.
- Population of approximately 26,000 residents
- Limited new housing supply due to build-out conditions
- High demand for large single-family rental homes
- Low housing turnover compared to surrounding cities
Colleyville Economic & Rental Market Snapshot
Colleyville consistently ranks among the higher-income communities in North Texas. Strong household earnings and property values support premium rental pricing and long-term tenancy, particularly for well-maintained homes.
- Median household income typically in the $150,000+ range
- Median home values commonly exceeding $700,000
- Median monthly rent often ranging from $2,800 to $3,500+
- Employment access to executive, professional, and corporate roles across DFW
Neighborhood Character & Housing Options
Colleyville is characterized by low-density residential zoning, large lots, and custom-built homes. Rental properties appeal to tenants seeking premium housing, strong privacy, and access to highly regarded local amenities and surrounding communities.
- Estate Neighborhoods: Large custom homes with long-term rental appeal for executive and relocation tenants.
- Established Residential Areas: Well-maintained neighborhoods with strong homeowner and renter expectations.
- Commuter Accessibility: Convenient access to Highway 121, Highway 26, and DFW Airport.
Why Colleyville Is Attractive for Rental Property Owners
From an investment standpoint, Colleyville offers a low-volatility rental environment focused on quality rather than volume. High incomes, limited inventory, and strong community standards support premium rents and longer tenant stays.
- High-income tenant base supporting premium rental pricing
- Limited housing inventory reducing vacancy risk
- Strong preference for well-managed, high-quality homes
- Low tenant turnover compared to broader suburban markets
- Long-term value preservation in an established community
Overall, Colleyville, TX represents a high-quality and stable rental market. Property owners benefit from premium rental demand, limited supply, and strong community standards, making professional property management essential for protecting asset value and meeting elevated tenant expectations.
Why Local Management Matters
- Family-owned, Fort Worth rooted.
- Tier 1 property standards that keep homes competitive.
- In-house maintenance = faster service, better control, fair pricing.
- We’re small enough to know your property, big enough to protect it.
Texas Property Code and Lock Laws pertaining to Rental PropertiesWe comply fully with the Fair Housing Act
This means that you can not choose to disallow anyone that is a member of a protected class under the act. You can choose to disallow pets and not permit smoking in your home, but you cannot deny a service animal. If you have additional questions on the specifics of the Fair Housing Act, please contact us or view more information here.
Areas We Serve
Proudly serving Fort Worth and surrounding neighborhoods with trusted, local property management solutions.

